Within the home, the serving of food was subtly geared to the status of the person in the family. The killing of a chicken was an event. In a household of perhaps two or three dozen people, only the more important and elderly people, or a visitor, were privileged to eat it.
Favours and gifts and insults were expressed gastronomically. A visiting relative from afar who returned to be given vegetable soup, with not a piece of meat in sight, would think he had been insulted, or that the family was acting poverty-stricken in order to prepare him for a small loan.
Chinese Gastronomy, Hsiang-Ju Lin, 1960
I have been thinking about yumcha, Ante Babic said one day as we sat at our favourite tea house.
Oh yes? I said warily; Antes ruminations can sometimes be quite disturbing.
Yes, he said. Its not just about good food and indifferent tea, you know. I have come to the conclusion that yumcha which by the way the Americans call dim-sum, did you know that? — is a secret training system developed by the Chinese
Oh, you must be I started to expostulate.
No, dont interrupt, he insisted. Listen. Im convinced that it is a secret training system for essential life skills that Chinese well, all of us, really have to learn to get by and prosper in the world.
And you think we Chinese deliberately developed this, this training system for what? Our kids? I dont know why I was surprised; Ante usually has a conspiracy theory on the boil about something.
Well, anyone; he said. And it didnt have to be consciously developed; it could just have grown out of the basic spirit of the Chinese people, sort of an expression of your zeitgeist or
Never mind about that. Tell me what you mean. What training could you possibly get by lunching in a place where you just select the food from carts being wheeled around the room?! I was getting exasperated but admittedly a little curious at the same time.
Ante twitched his bushy eyebrows and looked smugly superior for a second before he leaned forward and said in a low conspiratorial tone, Ok just think about it. Yumcha teaches you all these things:
It’s not what you know, but who you know.
You have to be in the right place, at the right time, with the right people.
You must maintain constant vigilance.
Its the quick and the dead delayed decisions are fatal
Hold it, hold it! I snapped. Stop right there and explain what you mean.
Sure, he smiled. You have to know the right place, since not all yumcha places are equal some are horrible. If you dont know the right people at the door, you get put in the losers section where the food carts hardly ever go. If you arrive at the wrong time, there is just no food left at all.
Well, thats true enough, I said, looking around. But what about with the right people?
It should be three or a multiple of three people, since all portions come in threes, right? And heaven forbid you should bring a vegetarian to yumcha what could they eat? It would just ruin your lunch. Ante wolfed down a roast pork bun, leaving a rather macabre spot of red hanging from his moustache, but he continued regardless, fixing me with his eyes to emphasize the importance of what he was saying.
Learning to maintain Constant Vigilance is crucial. Let your attention slip for an instant and your favourite item has just flashed by, to be gobbled up by the next table along. While still looking at me, his right hand suddenly thwacked a spoon down hard onto a plate just starting to levitate away from the table, making me jump. He looked over and growled Leave it!!
Turning back to me, he said, There you go. See that? He indicated the retreating back with his chin. If you dont watch constantly, those busboys will whisk away a plate that was only half-finished. I was saving that bit of morsel for later.
He settled himself in and got back to his topic. Your point of view is everything, and you have to choose it deliberately, for your own advantage. What I mean is — he saw I was looking puzzled — pick the right seat. You must be looking in the right direction or you dont even see what choices you might have. It will all pass you by, and youll never know the difference, except that gnawing deep hunger will just get worse and worse.
Yumcha is truly the Arena of the Quick and the Dead, he went on. If you hum and haw and cannot make up your mind within ten seconds about whether you want something, those irascible cart ladies are gone better fish to fry, you know.
My mind was whirling from his melange of metaphor, but I was hooked, so to speak. But best not show it. Is that all? I sneered. Hardly a full system of life training
Oh no, he laughed. Theres heaps more. The importance of insider knowledge in life (such as who to book the table with, which table to request, what to order); math and negotiation skills (how to divide three portions into the number of people at your table, and what happens if you cant); and even the principles of good government.
Youre joking, I stuttered. How do you get that?!
Simple, he replied, stabbing a dumpling he had been chasing around with his chopsticks. Chinese custom when eating out as you know very well — is that He who Orders has to Pay. Now if that isnt a recipe for good government I dont know what is.
Most importantly, he went on, you have to be Daring! Well, or at least not too precious to try something unknown. Lots of people imagine what they think something might be, and then react to that instead of seeing what is actually in front of them and trying it. Well, they just tie themselves up from the beginning, and will never get anywhere! he said, pulling a thread of jellyfish from between his teeth.
The idea was growing on me. You know, you may be onto something I said. When I was younger, you never waited at the door to be seated in a yumcha place, you always just picked a table and went to stand behind the people already eating at it, until they got intimidated and left. And if you were the ones sitting down which eventually you always were it taught you not to be too easily intimidated, and that you had a right to eat like everyone else, but that there were lots of people in the world, and lots of them were hungry
Whoah! laughed Ante. I think you are getting it. You see what I mean? There is no way you could teach these skills in a classroom. And that is part of the point: what better stimulus than food to cement in some hard-earned life-learning skills? When we want to cement a friendship or some other relationship, we go out to eat, right? Food makes us more receptive, for better or for worse.
I think Chinese society at least tries to make it for the better, I said. Memories had come flooding back. In the old yumcha places, to mark the number of dishes consumed they used the character zheng4 ? which has five strokes. One stroke per dish, so they would just write the strokes in order until there was a total of five and the whole character appeared. They would then start another character. So they would then just count up the zheng4 characters, plus the remaining orphan strokes, and they would know how many dishes you had taken from the carts. The point is that zheng4 means Righteousness, and here across the bottom of your food bill would be a whole line of them.
Yep. Subliminal conditioning, Ante agreed. Or maybe they thought with all that righteousness you would be too ashamed to sneak out without paying. It must have been chaos with everyone standing around behind tables full of people eating.
Yes, but we like it that way, I confessed, my eyes misting. Noisy equals liveliness, Life in fact. Who wants to eat someplace that is silent like a tomb?
It would put you off your food, eating in a tomb. But now that I think of it, Antes eyes narrowed as he concentrated, the word for the primordial chaos is hun2 dun4 , isnt it? Exactly the same sound as the word for Wonton, as in Wonton soup. So that soup enshrines the early Chinese view of the universe: utter chaos until someone comes along and imposes order on it, by eating their way into it.
That was it. I was sold, convinced. Ante had really tapped into something here, a deep well of cultural wisdom transmitted through an everyday activity, a veritable Bah! Ante slapped the table, distracting me from my reverie. Even when you do everything right, sometimes life just doesnt deliver the goods. Like today, he said, looking around disgustedly. Lets get out of here.
He slapped down some money for the bill, then as I headed for the lift he grabbed my arm and pulled me away. Cant go that way, he said. They always shift tables between floors just about now. Always gotta have a viable exit strategy. Lets take the back stairs!
So we did.
This article was written by my husband, Steve Clavey for a Chinese Medicine journal.
8 thoughts on “Yum Cha as a Secret Chinese System of Life Training”
very deep Steve Congrats
very deep Steve I enjoyed the story
very deep Steve
He is deep. (:
I truly love your website.. Excellent colors & theme.
Did you make this site yourself? Please reply back as I’m trying to create my very own site and would like to learn where you got this from or exactly what the theme is called. Cheers!
Thank you for your comment about my website. I really like it too. It was designed by Jin & Co. If you scroll down to the bottom of the page you will find a link to his website.
Yum Cha dining out will never be the same. Enjoyed this dissection greatly. And chicken feet are one of my favourite dishes – the lesson being that one can overcome western cultural prejudices.
Listened to Gabrielle on Radio National just now (15/7/13). I also linked yr new story with Chinese history of the 20th century.
And I will seek out yr book ab yr mother as I find this transition period fascinating, having read many firsthand stories, published in recent years, about these times
I recently asked a Chinese woman (64 yrs, the same age as me) if she would tell me about her life experiences as a child & adolescent of the 1950s-1960s & a young mother in the 1970s, but she demurred (through her son, as interpreter), saying it was too hard to recall, meaning, I think, that she did not want to revive memories.
I can’t help but compare those years in China to my own happy & carefree childhood & adolescent life in Adelaide, SA.
If you can, please comment about this perceived reluctance so that I might understand better.
Best Wishes, Lesley.
Thanks Lesley. Glad you enjoyed the article.
Those were tumultuous times in China and many would want to forget them. On the other hand for the lady you mention it might have just been a cultural thing. Chinese do not tend to talk about their past or any thing personal unless you know them very well.